Search This Blog

Gone With The Wind: Thoughts On a Pivotal Novel

 The other day, I finished listening to Gone With the Wind. If I'd had a physical copy, it would have flown across the room.


I shall say I've never seen the movie other than a handful of clips, and of course I've heard the famous quote, "Frankly, my dear, I don't give a dam." I knew the book was set during the Civil War and that it's considered pivotal for its cultural and historical impact and the controversy surrounding it racially.

But that was the extent of my knowledge.

I thought it was an epic romance. 

I thought it would see our heroine grow up. 

I thought it wouldn't break my heart.

I was wrong, oh so wrong.

Yes, it is a romance, maybe even an epic one, but it's not the romance story I'd thought it would be.


Yes, it is a romance story about people who love, lust, use, and dislike each other, and Scarlett's shift from Ashley to Rhett makes for a wonderful plot. Personally, I found myself rooting more for Rhett than Scarlett. Despite his philandering ways, the scoundrel was deeply charming, and I loved that he never hid who or what he was.
But for me, the true romance of Gone With the Wind isn't between the characters. It is the romance they share with the South itself, and a way of life that is being brutally and justifiably torn away. As a woman born and raised in the South during the 1980s, I can attest firsthand to the pride that generations were taught to have in their Southern heritage.
Days after finishing the novel, I still find myself thinking about Ashley and his view of what was lost: the gentleness, the beauty, the slowness. Throughout the entire story, Ashley longs for an idealized past that is irreparably gone.
Ultimately, Ashley's love for that idealized version of the South is a perfect mirror image of Scarlett's love for him. And much like Scarlett's awakening to the real Ashley at the end of the novel, the reality of the South hits Ashley hard in the aftermath of the war.  

Then there is Scarlett: poor, blind Scarlett. We watch her transform from a spoiled, superficial girl into a cold, hardened woman who never acknowledges her own faults, regardless of the consequences.
This defensive blindness perfectly mirrors the South itself, both before and after the war. Scarlett survives brutal hardships and toughens her exterior, yet she never truly grows up. She remains entirely oblivious to anything that does not directly affect her.
Ultimately, her constant refrain of "I'll think about it tomorrow" acts as a shield against self-reflection. It stunts her emotional growth by allowing her to escape her reality rather than face it. The South also acts in this way, so often ignoring what's right in front of us because we can't or don't want to face it. Much like Scarlett, the South is still growing up.


In the end, for me, that is where the true heartache of the novel lies. It is the devastating sorrow of watching misplaced patriotic pride drive romantic young boys and stubborn old men into a war that would destroy them. It breaks my heart to look back at the prideful, willing blindness of Ashley, Scarlett, and the South itself. They chose a beautiful illusion over an uncomfortable truth, and the cost of that choice lost them everything. 


No comments:

Post a Comment

Chicken Tortilla Soup

 There's a great local Mexican restaurant we love that has the most amazing Chicken Tortilla soup. Like, I want to eat it by the gallon ...